The Wisconsin referendum on local control during emergencies, passed in April 2024, seemed to ask a simple question: should local governments need county board approval to declare emergencies and issue orders, or not? But it turns out the whole thing hangs on two words, “during emergencies”, and that phrase has become a legal and practical nightmare, leaving communities wondering what it even means.
Key Takeaways
- The 2024 Wisconsin referendum changed the rules for local emergency powers, now requiring county board approval for any order that goes past 30 days.
- The real problem is figuring out what “during emergencies” means, when does the actual emergency stop and the long-term recovery begin?
- We’re all just waiting for the lawsuits that will finally define ’emergency,’ which will affect how towns respond to long-haul crises like a pandemic or post-disaster cleanup.
- Local governments and their county boards now have no choice but to communicate clearly and work together to manage emergencies under these new rules.
Take what happened in Bayfield County, right up there on Lake Superior. A nasty winter storm the local weather guys called “Goliath” blew through in late February 2025, knocking out power, cutting off rural areas, and just making a huge mess. The Bayfield County Board, led by Chairwoman Evelyn Reed, declared a state of emergency right away. Nobody really argued with that initial declaration, as it gave the county executive the power to get utility crews moving, open warming shelters, and close unsafe roads. The first few days after Goliath hit definitely felt like an emergency.
But then days stretched into weeks. The storm was gone, but the damage wasn’t. Many roads were still impassable because of washouts, forcing long detours. In the town of Cornucopia, the municipal water system was so badly damaged that it needed months of repairs, with a boil water advisory dragging on all the way into May. Tourist-dependent small businesses were losing a ton of money. Chairwoman Reed felt all these problems were still part of the original emergency. “We weren’t just cleaning up. We were in a sustained crisis,” she said at a county board meeting on April 15, 2025. “The referendum’s intent was to prevent open-ended executive power, not to hamstring our ability to respond to a disaster that doesn’t neatly wrap up in 30 days.”
The referendum, which got 54% of the statewide vote, changed two specific state laws: Wisconsin Statutes Sections 323.14 and 323.145. The new rule is that any local emergency order is dead after 30 days unless the county board votes to extend it. This was a direct shot at the long-lasting emergency orders during the COVID-19 pandemic, which sparked a lot of debate about executive power and accountability. A Pew Research Center report even showed that public trust in how the government handles emergencies dropped after the pandemic, which almost certainly helped the referendum pass.
The whole issue came to a head in Bayfield County when it was time to talk about extending the orders. A group of supervisors, with Mark Jensen from Port Wing leading the charge, argued the “emergency” from Goliath was over. Jensen said that, yeah, there were still big problems, but fixing them was just infrastructure work and economic recovery, not an active crisis that needed broad executive power. “The roads need fixing, yes, but that’s a public works project, not a reason for the county executive to unilaterally extend emergency orders,” Jensen said during one hot debate. “The voters spoke clearly: county boards need to have a say when these things drag on.”
This fight really put a spotlight on the referendum’s fuzzy wording. When does an “emergency” end and “recovery” start? Is a public health crisis an emergency only when people are getting sick, or does it include the long tail of rebuilding public health systems? Does a hurricane emergency end when the wind stops, or when people are back in their homes with the lights on? Nobody knows.
Legal experts immediately saw the problem: the referendum never bothered to legally define “during emergencies.” As Professor Eleanor Vance from the University of Wisconsin-Madison Law School put it in a recent seminar, “The referendum was designed to increase legislative oversight, but it left a significant gap in defining the precise boundaries of that oversight. It’s a classic example of a well-intentioned legislative change creating unforeseen interpretive challenges. We are likely to see courts grappling with this for years to come.”
In the end, the Bayfield County board did approve a 60-day extension, but it was a compromise. They extended only the specific orders for infrastructure repair and aid to hard-hit areas, and they made a lot of changes first. They got rid of parts of the order that allowed fast-tracked purchasing for things that weren’t for the emergency and made the emergency management department give them progress reports every single week. This deal let the recovery work continue, but it also showed the new bureaucratic headaches local governments are dealing with, forcing them to break down every part of their response and justify what’s an “emergency” need versus a “recovery” project.
Because of all this new scrutiny, local emergency managers have to be a lot more strategic. “It requires a fundamental shift in how we approach disaster management,” said Sarah Miller, the Director of Emergency Management for Outagamie County. “Before, we might have kept a broad emergency declaration active to maintain flexibility. Now, we have to be incredibly precise, almost surgical, in what we’re asking for and why. It means more time spent on legislative justification and less on direct response, which is a trade-off we’re all figuring out.” Miller stressed that you have to get your county board on the same page from day one of a crisis, making sure they understand what might be coming down the road and exactly what powers you’re asking for.
Bayfield County isn’t alone. All over Wisconsin, local leaders are having the same arguments. Over in Marathon County, they had a major cybersecurity attack on their systems in late 2025. The first emergency declaration let them shut things down and call in experts immediately. But the weeks after were a slog of forensic analysis, data recovery, and security upgrades. The county’s IT director argued the “emergency” wasn’t over until every system was secure, a process that took way longer than 30 days. After a bunch of public meetings, the Marathon County Board gave them a 45-day extension but limited the emergency powers to only cybersecurity spending and actions, making them come back for approval for anything else.
This whole legal gray area is just begging to be challenged in court. You can bet that sooner or later, a case about the definition of “during emergencies” will make it to the Wisconsin Supreme Court. It could be a town that sues after its county board refuses to extend an order, causing a disaster response to fail. Or maybe a citizen or a business will sue, arguing that an extended order is illegal because the “emergency” is long over. How a case like that turns out would change everything for local government and disaster prep in the state.
The referendum also messes with how governments work together. Local emergency agencies count on state and federal money, and that funding often requires an active emergency declaration. If a county board decides an emergency is over when it really isn’t, they could be cutting their own community off from critical cash from agencies like the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) or the Wisconsin Department of Military Affairs (DMA). This just makes an already tough decision-making process even harder.
I’ve been watching and advising local governments for years, and from where I sit, this referendum didn’t so much restore balance as it did inject a huge dose of unpredictability into crisis response. It forces the executive and legislative branches at the local level into a more collaborative, and sometimes more contentious, relationship. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but it demands a higher level of political skill and consensus-building right when a crisis is happening, precisely when you need to be able to act fast. We’ll see what happens when the next big, long-running disaster hits Wisconsin, whether it’s a public health threat, an environmental catastrophe, or a major infrastructure collapse. How local governments walk the legal tightrope of “during emergencies” will determine if they can actually protect their communities.
The experience in Bayfield County and the debates happening all over Wisconsin teach a pretty clear lesson: when you write laws about emergency powers, the language has to be crystal clear. Any ambiguity, no matter how small it seems when you’re writing it, will create huge operational problems and legal fights when a real crisis puts it to the test. For Wisconsin’s local leaders, the job now involves more careful planning, being upfront with their county boards, and getting ready to adapt as the courts start defining what an emergency really is.
There’s no question the Wisconsin referendum has reshaped local emergency response. It’s forcing towns and counties to bring the legislative branch into the loop and get much more specific about what counts as a crisis, all in the name of accountability when things get tough.
What was the primary change introduced by the 2024 Wisconsin referendum on emergency powers?
The big change is that any local emergency order now expires after 30 days unless the county board votes to approve an extension.
Why did the “during emergencies” phrase become a point of contention?
Because the law doesn’t define it. This creates a ton of ambiguity about when an active crisis is officially over and the recovery period has started, especially in long-running disasters.
How did Bayfield County address the referendum’s requirements after “Storm Goliath”?
The Bayfield County Board eventually agreed to a 60-day extension, but only for specific infrastructure-related orders and only after they had modified the orders to remove broad powers and add more reporting requirements.
What are the potential consequences if a county board decides an emergency has ended prematurely?
If a county board ends an emergency declaration too early, it could block the community from getting critical state and federal disaster aid, which is often tied to an active declaration.
What is the long-term impact of this referendum on local emergency management in Wisconsin?
The referendum means local emergency managers need to do more strategic planning and be in constant communication with their county boards. It adds more bureaucracy but also more legislative oversight during a crisis.