The used car market, always a good tell for the economy, is still on a wild ride. We saw prices drop 3.2% year-over-year in mid-October, but don’t get too excited, they’re still way higher than they were before the pandemic. The market is recalibrating as a few different pressures squeeze it from all sides, and the data is starting to show what the future of used cars really looks like.
Key Takeaways
- Wholesale prices for used cars dipped 3.2% in mid-October from last year, showing a slow but steady market correction.
- The average car on the road is now a record 12.7 years old, as people hang onto their vehicles because of high prices and the simple fact that cars last longer now.
- The market is flooded with used electric vehicles (EVs), with inventory jumping by over 150% in the last year, which is great news if you’re in the market for one.
- Getting a loan is expensive, with rates for even prime borrowers creeping up to 8.5%, a fact that’s putting a serious damper on demand and jacking up monthly payments.
- Even with recent price drops, used cars still cost about 35% more than they did back in 2019, establishing a much higher new normal for the market.
Wholesale Prices Dip, But Not Dramatically
That 3.2% year-over-year decline in wholesale used vehicle prices in mid-October is a welcome sign for buyers, but it’s not a market collapse. I watch these auctions closely, and this is the slow deflation of the price bubble we saw in 2021 and 2022. Dealers are getting pickier. They aren’t bidding up every single unit that rolls across the block like they were two years ago, and that’s taking some of the heat out of the market. The pace of this drop is what’s important. It’s a gradual slide, which tells me there’s still solid underlying demand out there even as the supply of vehicles slowly gets better.
The Aging Fleet: 12.7 Years and Counting
The fact that the average vehicle on U.S. roads is now 12.7 years old is a massive data point. It’s a direct result of several economic pressures hitting at once. When the average new car is selling for over $48,000, and interest rates make financing painful, it’s just smart money to keep your paid-off, perfectly good car running for another year or two. This trend, which S&P Global Mobility data backs up, is also possible because modern cars just last longer with good maintenance. This means fewer people are trading in their vehicles, tightening the supply of late-model used cars and creating a boom for auto repair shops (a ripple effect most people miss).
EV Used Car Inventory Surges: A Buyer’s Market Emerges
The used EV market is a completely different story. Inventory has absolutely exploded, shooting up over 150% from last year. This has created a massive buyer’s market for anyone looking for a pre-owned electric. What’s going on? It’s pretty simple. The early adopters are now trading in their first-generation Teslas and Leafs for new models with better range and features. At the same time, automakers are pumping out new EVs, with some attractive incentives that pull people out of the used market. This huge influx of trade-ins is causing serious depreciation on some older models, especially those with smaller batteries. It’s a huge opportunity if you want to get into an EV without paying new-car prices, but do your homework on battery health before you buy.
High Interest Rates Continue to Dampen Demand
Even though asking prices are softening a bit, the biggest problem for most buyers is the high cost of borrowing. Average interest rates for a used car loan are sitting around 8.5% for prime borrowers, which is a world away from the cheap money of a few years ago. That rate hike makes a huge difference in the monthly payment. A $25,000 car financed at 8.5% for 60 months costs significantly more each month than the same car did at 4%, pushing it out of reach for many people. With the Federal Reserve focused on inflation, these rates aren’t likely to come down soon, so this will continue to put a ceiling on what people can afford to pay, no matter what the sticker price says.
The New Baseline: Still 35% Above Pre-Pandemic Levels
For all the talk of falling prices, you have to remember this: used cars are still valued about 35% higher than they were in 2019. This is the new baseline. Anyone holding their breath for a return to pre-pandemic pricing is going to be disappointed. The entire automotive supply chain has become more expensive, from labor to raw materials, and those costs have permanently pushed up new vehicle prices. Since new car prices act as an anchor for the used market, they’re propping up used values as well. This is our new normal. We might see some small dips here and there, but a big crash back to 2019 levels just isn’t in the cards based on the underlying economics.
The mid-October used car market is giving us a complicated signal: prices are easing but still high, people are driving older cars, and the EV segment is a whole different ballgame. If you’re a buyer, you need patience and a good calculator. If you’re a seller, you need to understand the new market baseline and set your expectations accordingly.
Will used car prices keep dropping?
Probably not by much. While we might see small dips, the market has settled at a new baseline about 35% higher than before the pandemic. A major price crash is unlikely.
Why are used car loan rates so high?
The Federal Reserve has raised benchmark rates to fight inflation, and that action makes borrowing more expensive for everyone. This trickles down directly to what banks charge for auto loans.
Is now a good time to buy a used EV?
Yes, it’s definitely a buyer’s market. Used EV inventory is up over 150% compared to last year which means more selection and better prices, especially on slightly older models.
What does the 12.7-year average vehicle age mean for the economy?
The record-high average vehicle age of 12.7 years shows that people are holding onto cars longer because new ones are too expensive, interest rates are high, and modern cars are more reliable. It’s a clear sign of affordability challenges.
How do today’s used car prices compare to pre-pandemic?
Even after some recent softening, used car values in mid-October are still about 35% higher than they were in 2019. This suggests a permanent shift in market pricing, not a temporary spike.